TT.TONY THOMASCHARTERED ACCOUNTANT
← All insights

FINANCE

The investment case should survive the approval meeting

Approve the assumptions, delivery responsibilities and review dates—not just a spreadsheet that produces an attractive payback period.

By CA Tony Thomas · Chartered Accountant · 4 minute read
Prepared

PRACTICAL PERSPECTIVES / FINANCE · AUTOMATION · AI

Treat the business case as a working agreement

A capital proposal often receives its most careful attention just before approval. After approval, project delivery, procurement and finance may each track different versions of success. The business case then becomes a document remembered for its headline return rather than a shared record of what was expected.

Build the case around a decision and a baseline. What happens if the organisation does nothing? What credible alternatives exist? Which costs and benefits change under each option? Give operational owners responsibility for assumptions they can influence.

Keep the scope explicit. This article uses a simplified cash-flow example to illustrate decision discipline. It does not prescribe a discount rate, a tax treatment or an approval threshold.

A simple case with visible assumptions

Consider fictional equipment costing AED 600,000, with AED 50,000 of installation cash costs. Assume annual cash operating savings of AED 180,000 and additional maintenance of AED 30,000. The estimated net annual cash saving is AED 150,000.

On these simplified inputs, initial cash outlay is AED 650,000 and undiscounted payback is approximately 4.33 years: AED 650,000 divided by AED 150,000. That calculation assumes the full saving begins immediately and is sustained. It ignores financing, tax, working-capital movements, residual value and the time value of money.

If the evaluation period is five years, the arithmetic sum of net savings is AED 750,000, exceeding initial outlay by AED 100,000 before the omitted effects. That surplus does not establish a positive net present value. Discounted analysis must use the actual timing and an appropriately approved discount rate.

The purpose of showing the simple arithmetic is to reveal how narrow the apparent benefit may be, not to recommend the investment.

Challenge whether a benefit becomes cash

An equipment vendor may describe labour hours saved. Those hours create a cash benefit only if they reduce an actual cost or enable additional profitable activity that would otherwise be constrained. Redeploying staff can be valuable, but the value should not be presented automatically as a reduction in payroll.

Ask operations to explain which shifts, overtime payments, external services or capacity constraints will change. Identify transition costs, training, downtime, integration and disposal requirements. Separate recurring savings from one-off effects.

Check the baseline against observed operations. Comparing new equipment with an unrealistic assumption that current machinery needs no repairs can distort the decision. Conversely, loading every existing overhead into the new option can make a sound project look unattractive.

Use a benefit register with a calculation, evidence source, owner, timing and verification method. If a benefit cannot yet be substantiated, leave it as a sensitivity rather than quietly including it in the base case.

Test the assumptions that can overturn the choice

In the example, a 20% reduction in the AED 180,000 gross annual savings brings them to AED 144,000. After AED 30,000 maintenance, annual net savings fall to AED 114,000 and simple payback extends to about 5.70 years.

A six-month commissioning delay also changes the timing of savings while some project costs may already have been paid. Model the delay as a timing event rather than reducing every year's benefit by an arbitrary percentage.

Run sensitivities on a small number of decision-relevant drivers: achievable output, downtime, energy costs, maintenance and implementation date. Avoid a table of dozens of scenarios with no explanation of what management would do differently.

Identify break points and responses. If savings depend on a particular production volume, establish who monitors that volume and when the investment should be reconsidered. A sensitivity is useful when it changes a question, an approval condition or a delivery plan.

Connect approval to implementation

Agree the approved scope, funding envelope, expected commissioning date and change-control process. Identify who authorises deviations and who updates the financial assessment. A purchase order is evidence of a commitment, not proof that the benefits have started.

Keep accounting decisions separate from investment appraisal. Capitalisation, useful life, depreciation and impairment require assessment under the applicable reporting framework. An attractive forecast return does not establish the correct accounting treatment.

Ask for evidence of operational acceptance and record the actual date the asset becomes available for its intended use where relevant to the accounting assessment. Maintain the links between procurement, asset records, project costs and the approved business case.

Review results without moving the baseline

At agreed intervals, compare actual costs, timing and benefits with the approved version. Show scope changes separately. Do not replace the original assumptions and then claim that the project met a newly revised target.

A post-investment review should explain what happened and what the organisation will do differently. It is most useful when project teams can report estimation errors and implementation problems honestly.

The enduring deliverable is a decision record that survives personnel changes: approved assumptions, benefit owners, actual cash flows and lessons for the next case. The spreadsheet is one part of that record; operational accountability is what makes it useful.

About CA Tony Thomas

Chartered Accountant based in the UAE, with over eight years of experience across financial reporting, taxation, treasury, audit and internal controls. Previous professional experience includes Ernst and Young (EY).

More about Tony ↗
Perspective & scope

Personal educational perspective, independent of my employer. All business examples and figures are fictional and illustrative. Proposed workflows do not claim completed deployments or measured productivity gains. This is not entity-specific accounting, tax, legal or investment advice. Apply professional judgment, the applicable reporting framework and your organisation’s approval and data-protection policies.

Explore the AI Finance Lab roadmap · Discuss these ideas