TT.TONY THOMASCHARTERED ACCOUNTANT
← All insights

FINANCE & DECISION-MAKING

Profit is not
the whole picture.

Five questions to ask before turning a financial report into a business decision.

By Tony Thomas · Chartered Accountant
· 5 minute read

A report can show rising sales and still leave a business short of cash. A profitable order can require more funding than expected. Good decisions begin by connecting the income statement to the timing of receipts, payments and commitments.

My experience in audit, taxation and reporting informs a simple approach: test the information, understand the drivers and make the next action explicit. Here are five questions I would bring to a financial review.

THE DECISION PATH
  1. 01 · TrustIs the information reliable?
  2. 02 · ExplainWhat changed the margin?
  3. 03 · FundWhen will cash move?
  4. 04 · ChallengeWhat could change the outcome?
  5. 05 · ActWho does what, by when?

1. Can we trust the starting point?

Before discussing performance, check whether the period is complete. Are the bank balances reconciled? Have significant invoices and accruals been recorded in the correct period? Do unusual movements have supporting evidence?

An audit mindset is useful here: a precise number is not automatically a reliable number. Identify estimates, unresolved differences and assumptions before they become the basis of a commitment.

2. Is growth improving the economics?

Compare revenue with gross profit and gross margin. Then separate changes in selling prices, purchase costs, volumes and product mix. A higher sales total may conceal discounting or a shift towards lower-margin work.

Illustrative monthly performance · AED
MeasureMonth AMonth B
Revenue500,000600,000
Cost of sales350,000444,000
Gross profit150,000156,000
Gross margin30%26%

Sales increased by 20%, but gross profit increased by only 4%. Gross margin fell by 4 percentage points. This does not automatically mean the growth is undesirable; it means the next question should be whether the extra contribution justifies the additional operating costs, capacity and cash required.

Hypothetical figures for illustration only; not results from an employer or client. Gross profit = revenue less cost of sales. Gross margin = gross profit ÷ revenue.

3. Will the cash arrive when we need it?

Review customer collection dates alongside supplier payments, payroll and other commitments. Look at overdue receivables and slow-moving inventory, rather than relying on a single closing bank balance.

For example, assume an additional order generates AED 100,000 of revenue and has AED 74,000 of direct costs. It offers AED 26,000 of gross profit before other expenses. If all direct costs must be paid before the customer pays, the business needs AED 74,000 of interim funding for that order. The profit is not a substitute for that funding.

This simplified example assumes no customer deposit and excludes overheads, tax, financing costs and other cash movements. A real forecast must include those items. IAS 7 explains the distinction between profit and operating cash flow through adjustments for non-cash items and the timing of operating receipts and payments. Source: IFRS Foundation, IAS 7.

4. Which assumptions could change the answer?

Prepare a base case and a downside case. What happens if the customer pays 30 days later, costs rise, or the order is smaller than expected? Specify the cash buffer and the conditions under which the decision should be revisited.

Bring the taxation lens into the review as well: identify the applicable obligations, documentation and payment timing before finalising the forecast. Do not assume accounting profit equals taxable profit or that every accounting expense receives the same tax treatment. The assessment depends on the jurisdiction and transaction; this article does not prescribe tax rates or treatments.

5. What decision follows from the report?

End the review with a short decision note. A report becomes useful when someone knows what to do, what evidence supports it and when to check the result.

A five-line decision note
  • Decision: What are we approving, changing or deferring?
  • Evidence: Which reliable figures and assumptions support it?
  • Cash: What funding is needed, and when?
  • Risk: What would cause us to reconsider?
  • Accountability: Who owns the action and the review date?

In the order example, a practical response might be to negotiate a customer deposit, stage delivery or align supplier terms with collections before committing. The best option depends on commercial terms and the customer's circumstances. The value of finance is making those trade-offs visible before the decision is made.

General educational perspective, not advice on a specific business or tax position. Views are personal and independent of my employer.

Discuss a finance perspective ↗